Tonight an HD war online broke out. YouTube appears to have turned on HD video. Now Facebook jumps into the fray with true 720p HD 16:9 widescreen video. This is HUGE for those of us who have HD camcorders.
But also Vimeo and SmugMug have turned on HD video before.
Why is this important? Well, a bunch of people just received their Canon 5D Mark II cameras that do HD video. So does the Nikon D90. Look at the video that SmugMug CEO Don MacAskill did with his. That shows off SmugMug’s HD goodness.
Or look at Joi Ito’s videos from his 5D which use Vimeo’s video system.
Of course, we have exclusive video from Facebook which explains these features. Here’s a video with Chris Putnam, who runs the Facebook video team.
TechCrunch also covers the new Facebook features.
We’re trying to upload a 720p video to all of these services to see which ones have the best quality and features. Which one are you going to use if you have an HD camcorder? We should have a test video up soon.
UPDATE: this news has already started a long conversation on FriendFeed.
UPDATE 2: Chris Putnam, who was featured in my video, has posted a blog post about these changes and TechMeme has more posts about Facebook’s new video.
i need to admit that don’s video looks completely fake – i guess it’s that damn good 🙂 but facebook said on your video that they only do 720p – would don’s video look as clear on 720?
LikeLike
i need to admit that don’s video looks completely fake – i guess it’s that damn good 🙂 but facebook said on your video that they only do 720p – would don’s video look as clear on 720?
LikeLike
allen: the difference between 720p and 1080p is very hard for a human eye to discern. We’ll definitely test it out. My producer is getting a Canon 5D MKII too, just to try it out. By the way, the file sizes we’re uploading are massive. Rocky is uploading a 720p to all these services that’s 32 seconds long. Size? 228mb. Wow.
LikeLike
allen: the difference between 720p and 1080p is very hard for a human eye to discern. We’ll definitely test it out. My producer is getting a Canon 5D MKII too, just to try it out. By the way, the file sizes we’re uploading are massive. Rocky is uploading a 720p to all these services that’s 32 seconds long. Size? 228mb. Wow.
LikeLike
Great news, vive HD!
Just got my Canon hf11, very nice. The only catch is that the AVCHD is a little expensive to edit (as reported).
BTW, which encoding format the MKII is using? It says Quicktime 1080p H.264, does that mean it is a .mov? What is the difference with AVCHD?
LikeLike
Great news, vive HD!
Just got my Canon hf11, very nice. The only catch is that the AVCHD is a little expensive to edit (as reported).
BTW, which encoding format the MKII is using? It says Quicktime 1080p H.264, does that mean it is a .mov? What is the difference with AVCHD?
LikeLike
I assume you mean Nikon D90, right?
LikeLike
I assume you mean Nikon D90, right?
LikeLike
I uploaded a particularly tricky 720p video; sun glinting off water, with the whole scene panning… the difference in quality between YouTube standard and YouTube HD is quite amazing, check it out:
Source video: 720p MP4 (H.264) at 7500kbits/s
LikeLike
I uploaded a particularly tricky 720p video; sun glinting off water, with the whole scene panning… the difference in quality between YouTube standard and YouTube HD is quite amazing, check it out:
Source video: 720p MP4 (H.264) at 7500kbits/s
LikeLike
James: can you upload the same video to Facebook? It doesn’t look that great here, very compressed on YouTube.
LikeLike
James: can you upload the same video to Facebook? It doesn’t look that great here, very compressed on YouTube.
LikeLike
Here you go Robert…
http://www.facebook.com/video/video.php?v=37991674405
Quality is fine, but I’m only getting about 5fps playback on my MacBook Pro 2ghz, whereas YouTube HD playback is silky smooth.
I must say however, the uploading and notification experience on Facebook was better. But the poor playback is killing it for me.
LikeLike
Here you go Robert…
http://www.facebook.com/video/video.php?v=37991674405
Quality is fine, but I’m only getting about 5fps playback on my MacBook Pro 2ghz, whereas YouTube HD playback is silky smooth.
I must say however, the uploading and notification experience on Facebook was better. But the poor playback is killing it for me.
LikeLike
I really like the idea that everyone is going HD but I that means that we now have a longer workflow.
More time for transfers. More time for encodes. More time for uploads. More time for downloads.
I look forward to when we can get HD processing times lower that what SD is at now.
LikeLike
I really like the idea that everyone is going HD but I that means that we now have a longer workflow.
More time for transfers. More time for encodes. More time for uploads. More time for downloads.
I look forward to when we can get HD processing times lower that what SD is at now.
LikeLike
I just uploaded an HD video from my d90 to youtube, I’m not getting the watch in HD link, not sure what the deal is. Scouring forums to see what the matter is, no dice. Anybody got help for me?
LikeLike
I just uploaded an HD video from my d90 to youtube, I’m not getting the watch in HD link, not sure what the deal is. Scouring forums to see what the matter is, no dice. Anybody got help for me?
LikeLike
Guess i have to export it to H.264 5000kbits before uploading, I was just uploading the video directly from the camera. What a pain.
LikeLike
Guess i have to export it to H.264 5000kbits before uploading, I was just uploading the video directly from the camera. What a pain.
LikeLike
Guys,
Try ooyala.com for HD video hosting. I did some tests and found it the best on the web so far.
LikeLike
Guys,
Try ooyala.com for HD video hosting. I did some tests and found it the best on the web so far.
LikeLike